Thistles in Oklahoma and Their Identification
In 1994 a Thistle Law, was enacted in four counties in northeastern Oklahoma. Amended in 1995, 1998, and 1999, it now declares musk, scotch, and Canada thistles to be noxious weeds and public nuisances in all counties of the state. Expect additional amendments and changes in this law for several years.
Oklahoma’s Thistle Law has caused many landowners concern because there is considerable confusion about which thistles may be present on their land and which ones must be controlled. There are currently about a dozen different purple-flowered spiny thistles growing in Oklahoma. The purpose of this publication is identify accepted common names of introduced thistles with pictures and to provide information about them and some of the native thistles. Some other plants that also are referred to as thistles, e.g., Russian thistle (Salsola tragus), bull thistle or bullnettle (Cnidoscolus texanus), and spiny sowthistle (Sonchus asper), are not included in this identification guide
Native thistles are not major threats because insects and diseases keep them in check; thus, they generally do not form troublesome populations. Commonly encountered species include wavyleaf (Cirsium undulatum), distributed statewide; yellowspine (Cirsium ochrocentrum), in western Oklahoma; tall thistle (Cirsium altissimum), in central and eastern Oklahoma; and yellow thistle (Cirsium horridulum), in southeastern Oklahoma. Four other native Cirsium species have been identified, but are rarely encountered.
Introduced “Invasive” Thistles
Five invasive thistles identified in Oklahoma are from Europe and Asia and represent four genera. Diseases and insects that normally would affect them are not present in the state, thus heavy infestations often develop. The current Thistle Law is directed at only three of the five species. However, all introduced thistles should be considered invasive.
(Cirsium vulgare) is a robust and spiny plant that has been in Oklahoma since the 1960s. Isolated infestations occasionally occur, but severe infestations larger than one acre, are rare. Insects are commonly found on bull thistle, so insects that feed on some of the native Cirsium species may be keeping its populations in check. Bull thistle is distributed statewide.
(Carduus nutans) invaded Oklahoma primarily from Kansas and Missouri around 1960. Populations are fairly common in northeastern and central counties with some isolated problems statewide. The introduction of the musk thistle head weevil has successfully decreased the severity of infestations in the northeastern counties. Since initiation of weevil collecting with Missouri personnel in 1991, more than 300,000 weevils have been collected and released by Oklahoma Cooperative Extension Service personnel.
(Onopordum acanthium) invaded Oklahoma from the west. Infestations have occurred primarily in Roger Mills and Custer counties since the early 1990s; but in 1999-2000, new infestations were recorded in Love, Texas, Harper, and Woodward counties. Scotch thistle has large broad leaves. Both surfaces appear grayish-green due to thick cotton-like hairs. It is larger and will be more difficult to control than musk thistle. Herbicides are not as effective and there are no weevils or other insects available for biological control.
(Carthamus lanatus) was found in McClain County in the mid 1970s and later in Grady County. Infestations were identified early and eradicated. Distaff thistle is a spiny annual growing to 3 1/2 feet tall. It produces yellow flowers with red veins borne in spiny heads. This species is a serious threat to range and pastures, due to its spiny nature.
(Cirsium arvense) is an introduced perennial thistle that is widely distributed in Nebraska and other northern states. At present, it does not appear to be a major threat in Oklahoma. Several plants were collected in the panhandle counties in the 1950s, but currently, no infestations are known to exist in the state. In a 1998 survey of noxious weeds in Kansas, only one of the 14 counties adjoining Oklahoma reported any infestations of Canada thistle. In Meade County, which is directly north of Forgan in Beaver County, a small infestation was reported.
Control of Invasive Thistles
Preventing the spread and eradicating established populations of invasive thistles requires the full cooperation of all landowners. Proper identification of thistles and timely decisions about their control is essential. If invasive thistles are not present, use of feed and hay from infested areas should be avoided. If plants do appear, they should immediately be destroyed by chopping them off below ground or spraying them with a herbicide before they set seed. If an infestation is present, an integrated control program should be initiated. For details, see Fact Sheet PSS-7318, “Integrated Management of Invasive Thistles in Oklahoma,” available at all Oklahoma Cooperative Extension Service county offices.
3A. Tall Thistle (Cirsium altissimum). Photo compliments of Rodney Lyn, North Dakota State Extension Service.
3B. Wavyleaf Thistle (Cirsium undulatum). Photo compliments of Rodney Lyn, North Dakota State Extension Service.
3C. Yellow Thistle (Cirsium horridulum). Photo by Ron Tyrl.
3D. Yellowspine Thistle (Cirsium ochrocentrum). Photo compliments of Weeds of the West.
4A. Bull Thistle (Cirsium vulgare). Photo compliments of Rodney Lyn, North Dakota State Extension Service.
4B. Canada Thistle (Cirsium arvense). Photo compliments of Weeds of the West.
4C. Distaff Thistle (Carthamus lanatus). Photos compliments of Weeds of the West.
4D. Musk Thistle (Carduus nutans). Photo by Jim Stritzke.
4E. Scotch Thistle (Onopordum acanthium). Photo by Jim Stritzke.
Introduced “Invasive” Thistles
5A. Bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) is robust and impossible to graze because of its spine tipped leaf lobes that are spear-like. Life Cycle: biennial. Stems: stout, branched; with spiny wings extending downward from each leaf; 2-6 feet tall. Leaves: blades elliptic to obovate; upper surfaces prickly, green, leathery; lower surfaces light green with cottony hairs; margins with deeply cut lobes each stoutly spine tipped. Flower Heads: purple; top-shaped; involucral bracts with conspicuous stout green spines; flowering June-July. Source of illustration in Weeds of the North Central States.
5B. Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) is sparsely spiny and has numerous small flower heads in terminal clusters. Life Cycle: perennial; forms populations from horizontal spreading roots. Stems: slender; grooved; branching above and producing numerous flower heads; 2-3 feet tall. Leaves: oblong to lanceolate blades; both surfaces waxy and green; margins irregularly lobed and tipped with spines. Flower Heads: numerous; in terminal clusters; lavender to rose-purple; globe-shaped; 1/2 to 3/4 inches in diameter; involucral bracts without spines; flowering June-July. This thistle is not in Oklahoma at this time. If a plant matching this description is found, take it to your County Extension Office. Source of illustration in An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States and Canada.
5C. Distaff thistle (Carthamus lanatus) is robustly spiny, yellow-flowered, and capable of quickly forming large populations. Life Cycle: annual. Stems: stout; straw-colored; with cobweb-like or wool-like hairs; 2-4 feet tall. Leaves: blades oblanceolate, recurved; sessile; generally clasping stems; both surfaces straw-colored, with cobweb-like or wool-like hairs; margins irregularly toothed and spine tipped. Flower Heads: sulfur yellow; oblong; whorl of spiny leaves immediately below head; flowering May-June. This thistle is not in Oklahoma at this time. If a plant matching this description is found, take it to your County Extension Office. Illustration reproduced with permission, Dept. of Agriculture, Tasmania.
5D. Musk thistle (Carduus nutans) is easily distinguished from other thistles in the state by its silvery leaf margins, and absence of hairs or fuzz and large, nodding flower heads. Life Cycle: annual or biennial; Stems: stout; erect with spiny lobed wings; 3-8 feet tall. Leaves: blades oblong; both surfaces green and without hair or fuzz; margins silvery; deeply lobed, with 3-5 points per lobe, tipped with 1/8 to 3/8 inch spines. Flower Heads: deep rose to violet or purple; large (2-3 inches in diameter); powder-puff shape; involucral bracts purple tinged, large, ovate, spine tipped; borne on nodding stalks; flowering May-June. Source of illustration in An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States and Canada.
5E. Scotch thistle (Onopordum acanthium) is densely covered with fine hairs giving it a cotton-woolly appearance. Life Cycle: annual or biennial. Stems: stout; branched, with spiny wings extending downward from each leaf; 3-9 feet tall. Leaves: blades oblong; basal and lower stem leaves large, up to 18 inches long and 12 inches wide; both surfaces densely covered with fine hairs, bluish or grayish green; margins lobed and toothed with deeply cut lobes, each stoutly spine tipped. Flower Heads: reddish-purple; globe-shaped; numerous; involucral bracts with cobweb-like hairs, spine tipped; flowering May-June. Source of illustration in Weeds of the North Central States.
6A. Tall thistle (Cirsium altissimum) is the tallest species and the only one that flowers in the fall. Life Cycle: annual or biennial. Stems: stout; light green; hairy or fuzzy; leafy to summit; 3-10 feet tall. Leaves: blades ovate to lanceolate; sessile, often slightly clasping stems; upper surfaces green with few hairs; lower surfaces with white fuzz; margins mostly dentate and lobes weakly spine tipped. Flower Heads: light purple; shaving-brush shape; one or more leaves attached immediately below; flowering August-October. Source of illustration in An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States and Canada.
6B. Wavyleaf thistle (Cirsium undulatum) has conspicuously wavy and whitish leaves. Life Cycle: perennial. Stems: thick; stout; whitish; with matted hairs and fuzz; 1-4 feet tall. Leaves: blades lanceolate to oblong; upper ones sessile and often winged; lower ones petioled; both surfaces densely fuzzy; upper surfaces greenish-gray; lower surfaces whitish; margins strongly wavy and lobes tipped with 1/8-1/4 inch spines. Flower Heads: pink to wine-red; globe or shaving-brush shape; flowering June-July. Source of illustration in An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States and Canada.
6C. Yellow thistle (Cirsium horridulum) has flower heads that are buff-yellow to reddish-purple or white and subtended by a distinct whorl of spiny leaves. Life Cycle: biennial or perennial. Stems: thick; stout; with scattered long delicate hairs; leafy to summit; 2-5 feet tall. Leaves: blades mostly oblong; upper ones sessile and often winged; lower ones petioled; both surfaces green and mostly without hair; margins dissected into spine tipped lobes. Flower Heads: buff-yellow to reddish-purple or rarely white; whorl of spiny leaves immediately below each flower head; flowering June-July. Source of illustration in An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States and Canada.
6D. Yellowspine thistle (Cirsium ochrocentrum) has leaves and bracts armed with numerous stiff yellow spines. Life Cycle: biennial or short-lived perennial. Stems: stout; matted with whitish hairs and fuzz; 2-5 feet tall. Leaves: blades lanceolate to oblong; upper ones sessile and often winged; lower ones petioled; both surfaces very fuzzy; upper surfaces greenish-gray; lower surfaces whitish; margins deeply cut into stiff spear-like lobes tipped with 1/4-3/8 inch spines. Flower Heads: purple; globe-shaped; involucral bracts with cobweb-like hairs and tipped with yellow spines; flowering June-July. Source of illustration in An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States and Canada.
Assistant Professor and Extension Weeds Specialist
Ronald J. Tyrl
Professor of Botany